12 December 2017

Aerospike vs Redis vs Tarantool

I have been working on a project where we have to store application data (clicks, views, mentions,...etc) in order to do some analytics later on on the data. There are several ways to architect a solution for this kind of problem and although in the past I architected a similar solution to this problem using Apache Kafka and the Citus extension for PostgreSQL this time we decided to use an in-memory storage engine and implement a batch job that regularly aggregates the data and stores it in PostgreSQL.

The question was which in-memory storage engine should we go for? In this post, I will compare three promising tools and do some performance testing on them in order to better evaluate which one to go with. Before I start I have to mention that I am slightly biased towards Redis because I have used it regularly in the past and know my way around it but after having now worked with both Aerospike and Tarantool I have to say that all of them are worthy candidates.

Test Setup

The tests are run on AWS. I use terraform to provision the infrastructure. The picture below shows an overview of the infrastructure. The tools were provisioned as single instances on their own nodes:
YCSB-tester on  a c4.2xlarge (This instance was used to run YCSB tool to perform the tests)
Redis-tester(v. 4.0.6) on a m4.xlarge
Tarantool-tester(v. 1.8) on a m4.xlarge
Aerospike-tester(v. on a m4.xlarge
Elasticache-tester(v. 3.2.4) on a cache.m4.xlarge